Andres Dominguez III | 16 February, 2026
Landlords in Utah face this question anytime they get new quotes for their rental property insurance. It’s important for you as a landlord in Utah to be informed on what these terms mean, how they impact you, and what benefits (or drawbacks) you can expect from these coverages.
Replacement Cost & Actual Cash Value are not coverages. Rather, they are two different “Valuation Methods” that determine YOUR final payout on an insurance claim. Insurance carriers use both of these methods to calculate how much they will pay on a covered loss.
Now that you know what these terms are, let’s discuss the main difference between these two methods. Although they sound similar, they are very different and have a large impact on how your loss is calculated.
Actual Cash Value (ACV)
This Valuation Method means that the carrier will pay for what the damaged item was worth at the time of the loss, NOT what it costs to replace it brand new. Carriers calculate this by determining first the item’s replacement cost (how much it will cost to replace the item brand new in today’s dollars) and then subtracting the depreciation depending on the item’s age at the time of the loss. The older the damaged item, the more depreciation will be applied, and thus resulting in a smaller payout. In short, the older the item, the less your payout will be. Keep in mind, every carrier uses a different depreciation schedule. It’s important to note that some carriers are more conservative than others when calculating the depreciation.
Actual Cash Value = Replacement Cost – Depreciation
As an informed Landlord, you should take this into account when getting quotes. An ACV landlord policy will usually be cheaper than a Replacement Cost policy because the insurance company will end up paying less on a claim due to the depreciation. However, cheaper does not always mean better–it simply means you will receive less funds to repair or replace your damaged property due to the depreciation.
Example:
A 15-year-old roof costs $15,000 to replace today.
If depreciation is calculated at 50%, your ACV payout would be $7,500 (minus your deductible).
That $7,500 difference comes directly out of your pocket.
If you are unsure whether your current policy has ACV or Replacement Cost, you can contact our agency at 801-262-1551 for a free, no-obligation policy review. Request to speak with our Landlord Specialist, Andres, and he will be happy to review your current policy to confirm if it’s ACV or Replacement cost. We can also review your entire policy, identify gaps in your coverage, and suggest our recommendations.
Replacement Cost (RC)
This Valuation Method means that the carrier pays for the total cost of repairing or replacing the damaged item WITHOUT subtracting depreciation. If your policy is an RC policy, then the insurance carrier will pay what it costs in today’s dollars to repair or replace your damaged property with a new equivalent. RC policies provide higher claim payouts and less out-of-pocket expenses after a loss. However, you will pay a higher premium to secure this type of coverage on your policy.
It’s worth noting that Landlord Policies can have BOTH of these valuation methods on the same policy. For example, you can have RC on the Dwelling, ACV on the roof, and RC on the contents. Or any combination of the three. It all depends on your particular needs and desires. If you want less coverage and lower premiums, then ACV on all 3 sections of the policy could be a good combination. But if you prefer maximum payout and don’t mind a slightly higher premium, then RC for all three sections is the better package. Every company is different, some companies have the functionality to customize the application of RC and ACV to the different sections of the policy. So it’s important to consult with a trusted advisor to ensure you’re getting the coverage you need for your rental property.
Side-By-Side Comparison Table
| Feature | Actual Cash Value | Replacement Cost |
|---|
| Depreciation Deducted? | Yes | No |
| Claim Payout | Lower | Higher |
| Premium Cost | Lower | Higher |
| Best For | Cost-sensitive landlords | Cash-flow protection |
Which One Should a Landlord Choose?
There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question. It all comes down to your current situation and long-term landlord goals and desires. We usually recommend getting RC on as many sections as possible because the difference in cost between RC and ACV pales in comparison to the payout amounts once depreciation is applied. Not sure how your current policy is written? Many landlords assume they have RC coverage, only to discover that depreciation is being deducted at the time of a loss. You never know what’s covered until it’s not covered. Contact our office today for a free, no-obligation policy review with our Landlord Specialist, Andres 801-262-1551. Or you can also fill out the inquiry box below, and we will contact you within 24 hours or less.
3 Must-Have Coverages for Landlords | Landlord/Tenant Move Out Checklist | Utah Rental Housing Association
